Abuse victims blast Indianapolis archbishop

Abuse victims blast Indianapolis archbishop

They accuse him of hiding alleged at least 5 predator priests

SNAP discloses an Indy priest facing three pending lawsuits

But he was left off recent archdiocesan “accused” list, group says

So was another accused cleric whose was moved at least ten times

 “Victims, witnesses & whistleblowers should call attorney general,” SNAP says


Holding signs and childhood photos at a sidewalk news conference, a clergy sex abuse victim and advocate will publicly disclose for the first time that five credibly accused predator priests (including one who faces three pending abuse lawsuits) have been left off the archdiocese's 'accused' list. 

They will also

--prod Indianapolis’ Catholic archbishop to explain this omission, add the priests, and other alleged predators, to his “accused” clergy list, and

--beg anyone who saw, suspected or suffered clergy sex crimes or cover ups in Indiana to contact the attorney general who they say should be conducting an investigation into this crisis.


Tuesday, March 12 at 11:00 a.m.


On the sidewalk outside the Indianapolis archdiocese headquarters (“chancery”), 1400 N. Meridian Street, (corner of W. 14th Street) in Indianapolis, IN


At least two abuse victims: a Missouri man who is the St. Louis volunteer leader of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (and the organization's former long time executive director)


1) In October, Indianapolis Archbishop Charles Thompson posted names of "credibly accused" abusers on his website. http://www.archindy.org/criterion/local/2018/10-12/abuse.html


But SNAP has uncovered six publicly accused priests who have been left off the archdiocesan list. Three of them have attracted virtually no attention in Indiana.

SNAP wants Indy church officials to explain the omissions, include them and expand the list to include ALL alleged offenders who have been in the archdiocese: staff, nuns, bishops, seminarians, brothers and priests-living or deceased, ordained or lay, etc.

The first, Fr. David J. Marcotte, was suspended due to abuse allegations last month.



The second and third are Jesuits who taught at Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School in Indy: Fr. Allen F. Kirk (from 1968-1969) and Fr. Gerald R. Streeter (from 1969-1994).

Both were ‘outed’ in December by the Midwest Jesuit Province based in Chicago.



The fourth and fifth publicly accused clerics who have been left off the Indy list are:

--Fr. Crispin Butz. He was named among Franciscan alleged clergy perpetrators of sexual abuse in a 12/14 court document in Gallup NM. Early in his career, he worked in Batesville, IN and Louisville, KY. He worked in several NM towns (Gallup,Santa Fe, Albuquerque, Bloomfield, Cuba and Grants). He died in 2011 in Albuquerque.



The sixth is Fr. James J. Grear who worked in three Indiana cities (Muncie, Indianapolis, and Lafayette) and who faces at least three pending civil abuse lawsuits.

He IS, however, on the Lafayette diocesan "accused" list, which was released in September.


In the first lawsuit, filed in 9/18 in Hamilton County, John Doe 1 says that Grear abused him in approximately 1982. That same year, Doe disclosed the abuse in confession with then-Bishop Raymond Gallagher who instructed Doe to forget about it, keep quiet and ask God to forgive him.

In the second lawsuit, filed in 11/18 in Marion County, John Doe 2 charges that Grear bought him “expensive gifts, took him bowling, to the movies and restaurants and on trips” abusing him three times in Indianapolis. His parents reported the abuse to church authorities around 1975.

In the third suit, filed in 11/18 in Marion County, John Doe 3 says that Grear tried to recruit him to attend Brebeuf, “spent lavishly” on gifts for him, took him on trips and abused him three times around 1974-75 when he was a 12 and 13 year old altar boy. The abuse reportedly happened three-five times at Grear’s Indianapolis apartment.

SNAP says Fr. Grear had a very “troubling” work history, spending time in at least six states. In 1970, he was sent to the Lafayette diocese. Once, he was on an unspecified “special assignment,” (1971), once he was “unassigned” (1991-93) and four separate times, he was “on duty outside diocese” (1974-75, 1976, 1978-79 and 1986). For two long stretches, Grear was missing entirely from the Official Catholic Directory (1980-85 and after 1993.) He attended seminary in Little Rock,Arkansas and New Orleans, Louisiana.

Grear was at Ball State University in Muncie (1972), St. Francis of Assisi University parish (1973), Brebeuf in Indianapolis (1974-75) and the South Bronx Pastoral Center in New York (1987-89). Twice, he worked in Phoenix Arizona - at St. JohnIndian School (1976) and the diocesan headquarters (1977).

Grear’s name does not appear on Brebeuf’s website (https://brebeuf.org/) nor anywhere on the Indy archdiocesan site.

All three Grear accusers are represented by Minneapolis attorney Pat Noaker (612 349 2735, [email protected]) and were students and/or parishioners at Our Lady of Mt. Carmel parish in Carmel Indiana.

Other publicly accused clerics who worked at Brebeuf include Fr. Donald J. O'Shaughnessy (1964 - 1967), Fr. Michael E. Dorrler (1988 – 1993) and Fr. Bernard P. Knoth (1980 - 1988). 


2) The archdiocesan accused list omits the work histories, photos and whereabouts of the accused men. Where these priests are now is important because nearby parents and prospective employers should be warned about their presence. That's the single best step Thompson could take to prevent more horrific crimes against more innocent kids, SNAP says.

Where they worked and how they look is important because that information helps victims identify them. (SNAP notes that it usually takes decades for victims to come forward, so they were hurt long ago. They might only recall that everyone called him "Father Mac," not knowing whether he was Fr. Mack Smith or Fr. McGillicuty or Fr. MacArthur. And even parents who are long-time parishioners may have trouble remembering a priest who may have worked in their church just a few months before mysteriously vanishing with no explanation or a vague explanation from the diocesan hierarchy.)

Every time an abuser remains hidden, kids remain at risk, SNAP maintains. “Disclosing the truth is the best way to safeguard the vulnerable, heal the wounded and help the church move forward,” SNAP says.

3) Finally, SNAP is begging anyone who may have seen, suspected or suffered crimes or cover ups in Indiana to contact Indiana’s attorney general who the group says should be investigating all of the state’s dioceses.


David Clohessy 314 443 5915 AND 314 566 9790, [email protected], Zach Hiner 517 974 9009, [email protected]

SNAP Network is a GuideStar Gold Participant