Maneka is right about visa regulation for child sex offenders, and MEA should listen
By Geetika Mantri, The News Minute, January 25, 2017
In 2013, Pastor George Fernandes of New Hope for Children orphanage in Bengaluru received an e-mail from a British citizen Richard Huckle. Huckle wrote that he was interested in spending time at the orphanage and click photographs.
The unsuspecting pastor allowed George to stay at the orphanage for two days, not knowing that he was a convicted paedophile who had abused and raped up to 200 children in Malaysia.
Pastor George said Richard was never left alone with any of the children at New Hope during his stay there and no case has been filed.
Ernest Macintosh, a Nova Scotia businessman was in Nepal when he had 17 child sex abuse related charges against him in the 1970s. When Canadian police were hot on his trail, Macintosh fled to India.
As the Canadian authorities realised he was in India and wasn’t responding to summons, they began the extradition process in 2007. He was convicted of the 17 charges in 2011, pertaining to his abuse of street children in Nepal. No one knows what he did in India.
Paul Meekin served as the principal of a school in Bengaluru when, in 2012, he was charged for sending lewd messages to a 14-year-old boy. It was also found that Meekin had, in the past, taken an eight-year-old boy to Goa and behaved inappropriately with him.
Despite charges as well as multiple arrest warrants, Meekin disappeared after serving a 13 month sentence, to resurface in 2014 as a social science teacher at a Kuwaiti school under a different alias. His trial for charges under the Juvenile Justice Act and the IT Act were still pending in India.
Joseph Jeyapaul, an Indian priest was convicted of raping and sexually assaulting Megan Peterson, a minor at the time of the incident, in the US. He was sentenced to a year and a day's imprisonment in the US and deported back to India in July 2015.
But just six months later, he was reinstated as the head of the diocese of the commission for education in Ootacamund with the Vatican’s approval.
How and why do men like Huckle, Macintosh and Meekin come to India? Criminals like them are called ‘Traveling Child Sex Offenders (TCSO)’ and find it easy to enter India and disappear in the crowds here.
While many countries have strict visa regulations that prevent anyone with a history of sexual offense from entering their territories, India has taken its ‘Athithi Devo Bhava’ tradition too literally.
And wanting to break that tradition is Women and Child Development Minister Maneka Gandhi. She wrote to External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj on Twitter recently, asking for Indian visa rules to be revised so that people with criminal record of child abuse do not enter the country.
Maneka Gandhi’s suggestion came soon after American citizen John Kirk Jones was arrested in Hyderabad for distributing child sexual abuse material (CSAM) or child pornography online. Not only did he possess 29,228 CSAM files, Jones also confessed that he had been watching child pornography since childhood.
The Indian visa rules do not make declaration of criminal record mandatory. Further, in 2014, India started giving visa on arrival to nationals of various countries at its international airports, with no regard for their previous criminal record.
There are many cases of travelling offenders who relocate to another place simply to have access to victims they can abuse.
Vidya Reddy of Tulir, an organization which works in the field of preventing child sexual abuse, has been fighting for over a decade to regulate visa guidelines so that convicted CSA offenders are not allowed to travel to India. She says that as per scientific understanding, people who have a sexual interest in children never completely lose it, and at most can learn to manage it in a way that does not pose a threat to children around them.
“So when there have been convictions, I don’t understand why we need to put more children at risk by allowing them entry here,” she insists.
She points out that there are various types of cases she has come across: where the alleged offenders have charges against them in different cities but have not been convicted; those who have Interpol red corner notices against them but still manage to escape to another place before sentencing; those who have been convicted; and those who have their charges investigated but their cases have never come up for trial.
An example of the second category is UK national Raymond Varley, who was charged with sexual offences against children in India from 1989-1991.
Raymond was convicted in a CSA case by Britain in the 1970s. He was released some time in the 1980s and continued to travel and work as an English tutor in Albania, Serbia and Thailand. He then came to India where he was part of an international paedophile racket in Panaji, Goa. But before the CBI could arrest him, he disappeared to resurface in Britain in 2000 under another alias.
An Interpol red corner notice was issued against him on CBI’s request. However, he kept moving between Thailand, Britain, Mexico and Slovenia, until his arrest in Bangkok in 2012, after which he was sent to Britain. The Indian government’s request to extradite him was turned down by a Westminster court as Varley claimed he was suffering from dementia.
Vidya says that one cause of the problem lies with NGOs and other organisations that work with children and indulge in ‘volunteer-tourism’.
“Notice that most of these traveling offenders were volunteers, teachers and the like. Many NGOs invite foreigners to volunteer with them for a certain fee and in return, they can spend time with children, and sometimes are even allowed to live with them. It’s really scary how this puts the children at risk,” she says.
Vidya says that a good step in this direction is taken by the UK, which allows employers of UK nationals, and people who have resided in the UK to apply for International Child Protection Certificate (ICPC), which will tell them if the employee has any convictions or reasons why he/she should not work with children.
Among other countries, Australia also takes cognizance of travelling child sex offenders and mandates that a registered offender inform the authorities if he/she wishes to undertake travel. A foreign law enforcement agency will also be notified of their travel. Philippines also does not allow foreign nationals who are registered sex offenders to enter the country.
While Interpol recognises travelling offenders as those who travel to developing countries solely to abuse children, Vidya also recommends that apart from issues like terrorism, drug abuse that Interpol places more emphasis on, the organisation treat travelling offenders as priority as well.
Kushi, who works with Enfold, an NGO working for the prevention of child sexual abuse says that there is no question that a visa regulation along the lines Maneka Gandhi’s recommendation is required. Her colleague Pooja however, points out a caveat: “Conviction rates tend to be low in such cases. So, if the visa mandates that only convicted offenders are not allowed to enter India, what about the alleged ones?”
Vidya maintains that while some people would “fall through the cracks”, it is essential that only convicted CSA offenders be including in this regulation.
SNAP will be Representing Clergy Abuse Survivors in Rome!
We are taking the fight to Rome and are standing up for all survivors on a world stage! From February 19-25, Board President Tim Lennon, Seattle Leader Mary Dispenza, Los Angeles Leader Esther Hatfield Miller and Austin Leader Carol Midboe will be traveling to Rome for Pope Francis' Papal Abuse Summit.
If you are a member of the media and looking to get in touch with these survivors while in Rome, click here for our media advisory and contact information. If you are interested in connecting with a survivor in the US from your area of coverage, please contact one of the SNAP leaders in the US listed below:
- East Coast/DC: Becky Ianni (SNAPvirginia@cox.net, 703-801-6044)
- Midwest/Chicago: Zach Hiner (email@example.com, 517-974-9009)
- Midwest/St. Louis: David Clohessy (firstname.lastname@example.org, 314314-566-9790)
- West Coast / San Francisco: Melanie Sakoda (email@example.com, 925-708-6175)
If you are looking to help spread the word about the importance of this summit and for survivors to be heard, add your voice to the conversation on social media using the hashtag #PBC2019. Be sure to follow SNAP on twitter and Facebook and share our posts, add your comments, and let the world know that we are watching!Learn More