Choosing a Therapist

Mary Gail Frawley-O'Dea, Ph.D.
Executive Director, Trauma Treatment Center - Manhattan Institute for Psychoanalysis
Co-Author, Treating the Adult Survivor of Childhood Sexual Abuse: A Psychoanalytic Perspective
It can be a daunting task to begin looking for a therapist to assist in the journey of recovery from sexual abuse. It may be difficult to know what to ask, what not to ask, what are generally appropriate treatment parameters, etc. Since it is important to work with someone you trust, as well as someone you "click" with, these guidelines may be helpful in selecting the right person for you.

Consultations: You are looking for another human being whom you can trust to guide you through the sometimes treacherous shoals of recovery from sexual abuse. You have both the right and the responsibility to gather data to help you make a good decision. It is not unusual for someone to have one consultation session with at least three therapists before choosing someone with whom to work. Most therapists will charge for a consultation, and it is money well spent to be sure you make a choice that is healthy for you.

What to Ask at a Consultation: In addition to being a person in need, you are a consumer. Again, you have the right and the responsibility to ask a potential therapist enough questions to get a sense of the way s/he works and how comfortable you are talking with him/her. Some things to ask:

Years of Experience: How many years has this person practiced as a psychiatrist, psychologist, or clinical social worker?

Trauma Training: What specific training and/or supervision has the therapist had in working clinically with abuse survivors? Until the 1980's, there was little formal training available in trauma. Since then, many academic programs and postgraduate institutes have added trauma courses. Other therapists have sought out seminars, conferences, and supervision with clinicians more experienced with sexual abuse survivors.

Look at the Bookshelf: If the therapist displays a collection of books, look for titles on sexual abuse and psychological trauma. It gives you a sense of the person's interest in this field. Some people keep their books at home, though, so don't leap to conclusions.

Personal Therapy: Most clinicians feel it is imperative to have gone through their own therapy before or during their professional careers. Some postgraduate programs require that the therapist be in treatment during training. Some people disagree with me, but I think it is a fair question to ask a potential therapist if they themselves ever have been in treatment. It is NOT fair to expect the therapist to talk about how long s/he was in therapy or for what reasons. Most therapists also will not say if they themselves were abused, at least until well into treatment, if at all, and this is appropriate boundary setting.

Approach to Therapy: This can be a little tough to answer, but I think you can ask a therapist how they generally work. What do they think is important in therapy: changing behaviors, changing beliefs, identifying how past relationships continue to be played out unconsciously in the present? Are they active therapists who engage in a "conversation" or are they more quiet, speaking mostly to make interpretations? There are no right or wrong answers here, but the responses help you get a feel for what it might be like to work with this person.

Therapeutic Frame: What is the therapist's cancellation policy? It is not unusual for a therapist to charge for missed sessions depending on the circumstances and insurance cannot be billed for those sessions. What is the person's policy regarding between session contact - e.g. phone calls - if you are having a difficult time? What is the fee, and how does the therapist expect to be paid? For instance, some therapists collect only the co-pay from insured patients and wait for insurance to pay them the rest. Others want to be paid in full and let you collect the insured portion of the fee. Again, there is no right or wrong, but it's good to know ahead of time. Is the therapist available for more than one session per week if you need it?

Psychiatric Referrals: Does the therapist work with a psychiatrist who is also knowledgeable about trauma and to whom s/he can refer you if medication is needed? Don't be surprised if it is needed. Many survivors of sexual abuse greatly profit from antidepressants, anti-anxiety agents, or mood stabilizers for various periods of time. One has to suffer to recover but not beyond what is necessary to do the work of therapy. Medication often allows someone to make better use of treatment and recover more quickly. We know now that trauma effects the brain, not just the psyche. The new medications help a lot.

Limits of Confidentiality: Review the limits of confidentiality with your potential therapist. All therapists will break confidentiality if you are a lethal threat to yourself or someone else. In those cases, the therapist can and must do everything possible to protect you life and/or the life of another person. If you tell the therapist that a child is being abused, by you or by anyone else, s/he must report it. If you are in litigation, you should know that your therapist's records and/or sworn testimony legally can be supoenaed. The therapist can argue client privilege, but if ordered by a judge to comply with the supoena, s/he can be held in contempt of court for not going along. Beyond those limitations, the contents of your sessions and any other information about you should be held in confidentiality by therapist. In no cases, beyond these mentioned, should a therapist share information about you or your treatment without your written and very specific permission.

Therapist's Expectations: What does the therapist expect of you? What is his/her view of the therapeutic alliance and each party's role in it?

Contract: It is often helpful for you and the therapist you choose to contract for six sessions in order to come to a final decision about working together. At the end of six sessions, you both can review how you think it is going and whether or not it is a good match for you. This kind of beginning allows both of you a fixed time to decide to go further or to part company.

Once You Start: When you have begun to work steadily with a therapist, you may develop doubts about how things are going. Since therapy for a sexual abuse survivor often is rocky, it is important not to bolt without carefully considering with the therapist the reasons for leaving. If you don't hate your therapist at some point, the work probably is not getting done.

On the other hand, it is also important to feel that you can terminate a treatment if it really is not working for you. Since recovery from sexual abuse often involves a volatile therapy, it is a good practice to set the same kind of six-week contract before leaving that you did when you began. Once you feel that you want to leave, talk to the therapist about your experiences of the treatment and see if you can contract for a six-week mutual discussion of the issues before a final decision is reached. Many therapeutic partnerships that seem to be foundering have find it tremendously helpful to consult another therapist skilled in the area. Whether the therapy is then rescued or ends, both the therapist and the patient may feel validated and affirmed by having a consultation with a third party.

Do you like this page?

Showing 5 reactions

commented 2011-10-15 12:21:30 -0500 · Flag
I am a therapist and have worked with many survivors. Many therapists have had clients who have been abused. Their religion is not as important as whether they believe you, have other clients who have experienced abuse, have training in working with trauma, and who understand the more difficult issues that priest abuse creates. Ultimately you need to speak to several different clinicians and feel a sense of a good “fit.” Though obviously this may be difficult to do considering what has happened to you, developing steps to trust is part of your healing. You will want to trust their boundaries, professionalism, and commitment to treating trauma. You can always check to see if a therapist has had complaints by contacting the state board. Ask the therapist questions about their beliefs, training, experience and how they treat trauma. If something doesn’t feel right listen to that. Meet with several therapists before you decide. A therapist should be understanding of this process and encourage you to “shop” for the right fit. The Catholic Church has a fund that pays for therapy. If you have not taken steps to get that money, speak to someone who has. You are entitled to it. What happened to you was not your fault and the church is responsible for the care of those whose lives have suffered due to their negligence.
commented 2011-10-07 18:47:30 -0500 · Flag
I’m sorry, I am not sure I worded that right. What I meant is should a patient ask about their therapists religion because it might cause a problem. The other issue I was talking about is that would somebody have difficulty finding one who is NOT Catholic. The reason being that, if the Catholic schools do not mess a student up, they prepare students very well for college. That and almost all Catholic universities offer psychology as a major. It may be hard to find someone who went to a public high school, non-religious university, and is not Catholic. Hopefully, there are some out there.
commented 2011-10-07 02:14:21 -0500 · Flag
No way, tried that long time ago, was called a liar and was just looking for attention and if I didint shut up would go to hell for making such as accusation. Thats all I ever heard for years and I am starting to really think that people dont really care, I know that sounds bad but i am really trying to get out of my death wish and the local chapter in New Orleans and I emailed them and the request came back nondeleverable mail. Just the same thing that has happened for 40 yrs. Its really getting old and I hope you can understand my frustration.
commented 2011-10-06 23:23:20 -0500 · Flag
Would it be better or not if the therapist him/herself is Catholic? If so and it was wonderful for them would they not be a good choice if one has this abuse? Since there are a lot of Catholic universities and Catholic schools prepare students for college better than public schools (that is, if they don’t mess the kids up) I would think a lot of therapists would be Catholic.
commented 2011-10-04 22:02:15 -0500 · Flag
Thats all well and good to the people that have the resources and the funds. What if you have lost everything including wife,home,vehicles and living with other non family members, just to survive.
Our most powerful tool is the light of truth. Through our actions, we bring healing, prevention and justice.

Search & Translate